Is mass deportation unconstitutional?

Considering the Trump Administration’s deporting and evicting of immigrants

Since the Trump Administration moved into the Oval Office, there’s been major upheaval, with such actions as creating new tariffs, eliminating DEI (Diversity, Equity and Inclusion) programs, and firing thousands of federal employees across the nation.

But one of the biggest changes has been deportation. Along with these issues, we were curious… isn’t deportation of legal immgrants, citizens and people living in the U.S. with valid visas (such as college students) unconstitutional?

The National Immigration Law Center says this about the Trump Administration’s deportation: “Several of the Day 1 executive actions defy the constitutional and longstanding legal norms. The [current] Trump administration has, shockingly, attempted to unilaterally change the Constitution by depriving babies of their constitutionally guaranteed citizenship.”

We all know about the fact of birthright citizenship: even if your parents are living in the U.S. illegally, anyone born on American soil is deemed as a legal citizen (Fourteenth Amendment).

But what the National Immigration Law Center meant by “defy the constitutional and longstanding legal norms” was that the Trump Administration has ordered “the federal government to deny federal documents recognizing the citizenship of children born in the United States after February 18, 2025,” if either of the parents were not legal citizens at the child’s birth.

This means that millions of children around the U.S. no longer have their citizenship that the Constitution had previously guaranteed. Clearly, deporting children who are legally citizens is illegal, unconstitutional, and above all dehumanizing. The Trump Administration’s deportation of immigrant without a criminal history should NOT be happening and is an infringement on one’s constitutional rights.

In recent weeks, members of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) have detained college students, who have legal student visas, with plans to deport them. One legal doctoral student at Tufts seemed to upset ICE by co-writing an opinion essay for her college newspaper, protesting Israel’s policy in Gaza.

We, the Talon staff, support the Constitutional rights of these individuals, whether they are immigrant families trying to stay in the United States or legal college students expressing their opinions.

So do major organizations that support student journalism, including the Student Press Law Center, National Scholastic Press Association, Quill and Scroll, and the Journalism Education Association.

NOTE: Update on Tufts student.

Author

You may also like…

How M.A. can revive school dances

opportunity for improvement is school dances—an important part of student life that has the potential to bring everyone in the Minnehaha community together and create experiences worth remembering. Many students have noticed a growing interest in school spirit over...

Beyond the books

Teachers define ethics of their own AI use Artificial intelligence has emerged into the education system quickly. Many students argue that it is unfair that teachers can use AI freely but they can not. What are Minnehaha teachers actually using AI for? What do they...

From yard to plate: why you should grow your own food

As gardening blooms across the world, see how it benefits people’s lives Your last meal likely traveled 1,500 miles to get to your plate - the equivalent of flying all the way to Florida just for dinner. “It’s like my food is going on a vacation,” said senior Alex...

Staff editorial: Keep standardized tests optional

Few colleges need the extra data that misrepresents what so many can do Note to readers: The Talon’s View is our staff editorial. Each issue on the Opinions page, the staff editorial will address an important issue and give readers the consensus views of the Advanced...

Finding creative ways to teach neurodiverse students

How MA is setup to help students who face learning differences When it comes to high school students, some struggle more than others. At Minnehaha (MA), almost half of the school population has a certain learning accommodation that is in place due to a diagnosis....