Is mass deportation unconstitutional?

Considering the Trump Administration’s deporting and evicting of immigrants

Since the Trump Administration moved into the Oval Office, there’s been major upheaval, with such actions as creating new tariffs, eliminating DEI (Diversity, Equity and Inclusion) programs, and firing thousands of federal employees across the nation.

But one of the biggest changes has been deportation. Along with these issues, we were curious… isn’t deportation of legal immgrants, citizens and people living in the U.S. with valid visas (such as college students) unconstitutional?

The National Immigration Law Center says this about the Trump Administration’s deportation: “Several of the Day 1 executive actions defy the constitutional and longstanding legal norms. The [current] Trump administration has, shockingly, attempted to unilaterally change the Constitution by depriving babies of their constitutionally guaranteed citizenship.”

We all know about the fact of birthright citizenship: even if your parents are living in the U.S. illegally, anyone born on American soil is deemed as a legal citizen (Fourteenth Amendment).

But what the National Immigration Law Center meant by “defy the constitutional and longstanding legal norms” was that the Trump Administration has ordered “the federal government to deny federal documents recognizing the citizenship of children born in the United States after February 18, 2025,” if either of the parents were not legal citizens at the child’s birth.

This means that millions of children around the U.S. no longer have their citizenship that the Constitution had previously guaranteed. Clearly, deporting children who are legally citizens is illegal, unconstitutional, and above all dehumanizing. The Trump Administration’s deportation of immigrant without a criminal history should NOT be happening and is an infringement on one’s constitutional rights.

In recent weeks, members of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) have detained college students, who have legal student visas, with plans to deport them. One legal doctoral student at Tufts seemed to upset ICE by co-writing an opinion essay for her college newspaper, protesting Israel’s policy in Gaza.

We, the Talon staff, support the Constitutional rights of these individuals, whether they are immigrant families trying to stay in the United States or legal college students expressing their opinions.

So do major organizations that support student journalism, including the Student Press Law Center, National Scholastic Press Association, Quill and Scroll, and the Journalism Education Association.

NOTE: Update on Tufts student.

Author

You may also like…

M.A. plans new track

New surface to go with bleachers, storage and throwing ring This fall, the field at the Minnehaha Academy Upper School was renovated with a state-of-the-art field surface, as well as new lights and stands. After giving the field at the Upper School a makeover,...

M.A. aims to block space radiation

I.S.S. team designs, builds annual microgravity experiment A team of Minnehaha Academy students have been working with this vision in mind: It’s a crisp morning, and the launch pad is set and ready. Inside the resupply ship headed to the International Space Station is...

Best ice cream for summer

Top 10 options for premium scoops With summer right around the corner, prime ice cream season is too. And did you know that eating ice cream doesn't just taste good but can have health benefits too? According to Michigan State University ice cream, “contains essential...

Voiced or voiceless?

Do MA students have a say at school? It was a bright and sunny spring day during fourth-period chemistry. Sophomores had just had the weight of their big unit test taken off their shoulders and were sitting out on the science learning patio. Students laughing, basking...

Golf: grow or shrink the game?

Purists and rookies debate golf’s future and its etiquette For generations, golf has been a game of exclusivity and class - and many believe it should stay that way. Those who favor “shrinking the game” argue that keeping golf selective preserves its traditions and...