The debate over turf and grass

Minnehaha decides on grass for North campus but considers turf for South

Many schools have switched to artificial turf, will we be seeing it soon, too?

What if you never had to worry about the condition of the field before you played on it, or if you never had to worry about playing too much and wearing the grass down, or never having to worry about cutting the grass? These problems are all mostly solved by the switch to an artificial turf field. Of course, it isn’t that simple, or else we’d have it by now.

Here at Minnehaha Academy, the grass has suited as the home field for many sports for decades, with much help from the hard-working maintenance crew. But lately, the idea of replacing the south campus football field with artificial turf has been seriously considered. “It’s kind of something that says your school is serious about athletics,” said Athletic Director Josh Thurow. Many other IMAC schools have installed artificial turf, like Providence Academy and The Blake School.

The Blake School, in Minneapolis, provided the home field for the Wolfpack, which was artificial turf. Blake uses the brand SprintTurf, and they have been very satisfied with it. According to their Athletic Director, Nick Rathmann, the biggest difference after they switched to artificial turf was how often they used the field. “We are more efficient. Rain, snow or sun. We are out on the field.” They also have a rental group that uses it in the evening after their sports teams practice. “It stays in great condition no matter the weather elements. In the past [on grass], one bad rain during a game would ruin the field for the whole season.” The price for their field and the base was around $1,000,000, but they use a grooming machine after each 60 hours of play.

Providence Academy, in Plymouth, also has an artificial turf field as well as a winter dome. They use the brand FieldTurf, and their initial cost was around $900,000. The Athletic Director, Rick Johns, wrote in an email that the annual maintenance was minimal, and at most the cost was a couple thousand dollars for the yearly grooming. He added that with a turf field they can play through all weather conditions on a consistently safe and reliable playing surface.

 

The Varsity Wolfpack football team played home games at Blake, which was an artificial turf field. The Junior Varsity Wolfpack team played some games at the Middle and Lower school campus field. Freshman Jose (Tony) Avila-Tovalin played in games for both teams. “When you’re running, you can accelerate faster [on turf],” he said about the turf and grass game locations he’s played on.

According to the Startribune, the artificial turf company FieldTurf claimed that artificial turf would cost less in the long run. Artificial turf can cost between $600,000-
$1,500,000 initially, but has cheaper yearly costs. Grass fields are estimated to cost around $52,000 each year for maintenance, while artificial turf fields don’t need maintenance until after 10-12 years.

Author

You may also like…

Climate research censored

What impact does censoring have on scientists and everyday people? Global warming’s acceleration over the past decade has contributed to some of the hottest years on record. But as this climate crisis grows more prominent and new data is unearthed, is there anything...

Too cool to care? The issue of nonchalance

Why nonchalance isn't the best strategy Skinny jeans and side parts used to be the hottest things. Now, it’s being “detached” and pretending not to care. This behavior is known as nonchalance. Dictionary.com defines nonchalant as “coolly unconcerned, indifferent, or...

Service with a smile

Students can learn courage & generosity from Nance Murdoch From fighting for her life to being a grandmother to six, Nance Murdock has done it all. At the age of 19, Murdock was diagnosed with breast cancer. “It was bad because I had to go to chemo and radiation,”...

M.A. library growing amid national decline

Library Grows Despite Reading Decline Although national studies show a significant decline in high-school reading performance, Minnehaha’s library is expanding while many local schools, including independent schools, are cutting back on their libraries or even...

Recording vinyl history

Local music stores sport friendly rivalry Minnesota is certainly no stranger to the music scene. Being the birthplace of folk icon Bob Dylan and funk-rock pioneer Prince alone gives the state plenty of credibility. So it should be to no one’s surprise that the Twin...