Controversial scanners

By admin

Posted: November 2, 2010

The U.S. Transportation Security Administration has published images produced by its new body-scanning security technology, which is designed to preserve privacy while increasing airline safety.

New security system good addition to airports

By Meera Goswitz

Talon staff writer

Take off your shoes and belts. Remove your cell phone and keys.  Remove any other metal items from your pockets.

This probably sounds familiar: the process all passengers must go through before entering the gates at the airport. However, for the many students and faculty that will be flying over the holidays, there has been a change in the security at many airports. After last year’s Christmas day ‘underwear bomber,’ the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) has been scrambling to increase security. Recently, a new product called Advanced Imaging Technology (AIT) has been released, and currently, there are units in 58 airports across the United States, including the Minneapolis-St. Paul airport (MSP).

There are two types of AIT units; the millimeter wave technology produces an image of the body, but it doesn’t use an X-ray. The backscatter uses an X-ray to produce clearer images of the body. These machines not only identify metal objects, but they can also see other weapons that can be hidden on the body.

One controversy surrounding these machines (especially the backscatter units) is connected with  health concerns. Some question the amount of radiation a passenger receives while using these machines. However, AIT units all follow national health and safety standards, and the energy that is produced is thousands of times lower than the amount produced by cell phones.

But privacy, not health, is the main dilemma. The images produced by these units are very clear, and some argue that these images violate passengers’ privacy. However, the TSA reader sits in a separate room,  never seeing the passenger, and communicates with the other officer via headset. Also, the face of the passenger is automatically blurred out and the machines cannot store or send the images anywhere. Officers reading the scans are not allowed to bring in cell phones or any other device that has picture-taking ability. Many precautions are in place to prevent the violation of privacy.

This new technology creates a safer flying environment, and while not perfect they can spot more than a metal detector or pat down would. The units can detect plastic and other types of weapons and although it can’t see weapons hidden in body cavities, it is an improvement from metal detectors. So many people are arguing that the AIT units are a violation of privacy, when really they can stop someone from blowing up a whole plane.

Without the privacy precautions in place, these units would not be acceptable. However, the TSA has put many steps in place to secure all passengers’ privacy.

If we always shun new technology, where would we be? We must take steps towards improving our security and creating a safer flying experience.

You may also like…

Slideshow: SMB Football Wolfpack’s Section Quarterfinal Heartbreak Captured by Ezra Victor

Wolfpack won’t go down without a fight The SMB Wolfpack football team—a co-op of Minnehaha Academy, the Blake School, St. Paul Academy, and Hope Academy—faced DeLaSalle in the Class 4A, Section 5 quarterfinal on October 22 at Blake. Both teams showed great skill and...

M.A. Votes: Why students voted the way they did

Harris, Trump, No Vote or Other? Students explain their preferences On Tuesday, Nov. 5, Election Day, 344 Minnehaha Academy Upper School students voted in an all-school election. Results were reported in brief the same afternoon, with details reported in The Talon...

The end of an Era

Studying The Tortured Poets Department as Taylor Swift's Eras Tour ends                        Who, in what world, would ever, ever, pay thousands of dollars, for just one night of live entertainment? Taylor Swifts’ fans would.  But why? It can’t be just the lyrics —...

Sports consumption changing

How today's teenagers are engaging with pro sports Teenagers don’t seem to care about sports anymore— at least live sports. TV viewership for sports is dropping; many kids and teens have never attended a live sporting event. Social media has changed the landscape of...

Rollback to the future

How the Trump administration has and will continue to shape the climate crisis for generations The climate crisis does not pause for politics. From poisoned rivers to polluted air and shattered international cooperation, the Trump Administration’s blueprint for...