Free…but legal?

Posted: October 1, 2010

Many teenagers are tempted to get their music free, even if doing so is illegal.

Free music is popular, but is it legal? And what are the real costs?

by Jeffrey Riley
Talon Staff Writer

The internet has innumerable uses and functions that can make everyday life easier. From social networking to school work, general browsing to searching for answers, the web is a priceless tool.

One of the more common uses for the internet though is downloading music. Legally or illegally, people of all ages realize that getting the music online is simple, quick and easy. The problem arises when illegally downloading music is equally easy, if not more so.

“I don’t have the money to support my passion for music,” said Minnehaha Academy junior boy. “Downloading it for free is the only way to me.”

Free music appears to be a great deal and downloading it is as easy as a few clicks, but do the potential ramifications outweigh the temporary satisfaction of knowing you didn’t have to pay for your favorite song?

According to the Recording Industry Association of America, penalties for illegal downloading are steep. You may have seen in the beginning parts of a VHS movie, the FBI warning that if one copies the product, they are subject to a fine of $250,000 or five years in jail, or both. This principle applies to music as well. The civil penalty could be as much as $750 per song downloaded.

In a society where virtually everyone has access to the internet, and innumerable people are engaging in music piracy on a daily basis, it seems almost impossible that anyone person could be caught in the crosshairs of the law.

The RIAA in fact filed thousands of lawsuits against individuals in order to raise awareness and put an end, or at least slow down the unceasing piracy problem from 2004-2008. Although there is not another mass individual lawsuit in sight, it’s possible that, if piracy increases, it may happen again.

Until then, the RIAA is focusing on the broader problem by going to the source. Larger organizations such as BitTorrent and Limewire will be held responsible for encouraging and facilitating in the piracy business.

According to the Institute for Policy Innovation, piracy causes a staggering $12.5 billion in losses every year. Not only does the band, whose music is copyrighted, lose money, but a domino effect takes place. If the band is losing money, then so is the crew that works for them, and therefore aren’t able to produce as much.

While music piracy is illegal, there are bands out there that realize it’s the only way their audience will listen to their work. At a recent show at Station 4 in downtown St. Paul, Minnesota, several artists and bands said on stage “If you don’t buy our CDs, at least download them” with an implication that they would be downloaded illegally.

The exponentially growing music piracy business is taking its toll on the whole industry. From bands to record labels, illegally obtaining music is fast, easy, yet detrimental to the business. If the trend continues, bands won’t be able to produce nearly as much as even now, and soon there won’t even be any music to steal. If you wouldn’t shoplift, you shouldn’t engage in music piracy, for the fines can be much steeper.

You may also like…

Guthrie Theater Play Review: A Midsummer Night’s Dream

Under moonlit mischief and a pulsing musical heartbeat, Shakespeare’s classic comedy soars. Where laughter, live music, and theatrical chaos combine to create an unforgettable Midsummer night. Renowned for its romance, pranks, and magical mayhem, Shakespeare’s A...

1-on-1 with Izzy Daniel

The Toronto Sceptres rookie reflects on her 2nd game in her home state Izzy Daniel, a Minnesota native and 2019 Ms. Hockey finalist, played her second game back in her home state while playing for Toronto this season. With Toronto picking up their first win this...

The Hidden Dangers of Overdosing

Increasing OD risk, RN talks about the effects of accidental teenage overdoses and how they impact everyone. A Local Nurse’s Perspective on the Teen Epidemic  At Fairview Hospital in Minnesota, Sarah Curry, a registered nurse (RN), has witnessed firsthand the...

Running for gold

Spanish teacher's life filled with adventure, resilience You are running through the Amazon, gold in hand, scared of who and what lies ahead. You think you hear voices, where will you go? What will you do? Your life may be in danger. This is how Spanish teacher Julio...

Slideshow: SMB Football Wolfpack’s Section Quarterfinal Heartbreak Captured by Ezra Victor

Wolfpack won’t go down without a fight The SMB Wolfpack football team—a co-op of Minnehaha Academy, the Blake School, St. Paul Academy, and Hope Academy—faced DeLaSalle in the Class 4A, Section 5 quarterfinal on October 22 at Blake. Both teams showed great skill and...